Sonadow
SonicXShadow

Name: Kashito91 (Signed) · Date: November 30, 2007 5:52 AM · For: Questions and Misinterpretation
cursed cliffie twists


Name: Mechaknucles (Signed) · Date: September 22, 2007 2:38 PM · For: Disappearing Act
"'. . .[m]y point is that Shadow is a powerful, and possibly confused creature. He has the power to do great harm to all of us; I just want you to be on your toes. He might be on our side, but just in case, please be careful'" (More Than A Friendship).
I quote this because you have one error that occurs twice. Right after "side," there is a comma that should not be there. IT is because the second clause is dependent because it lacks a subject. It occurs again after the word "powerful." I like this story, but grammatical errors are bringing you down! 7/10! This is interesting, but I hope you remembered to add the Psychological change over of Sonic turning from Amy to Shadow!

Author's Response: Funny thing about the commas is that when I'm writing, I always feel like I'm using too many of them. It is a little nagging feeling much like the old "did I live the oven on" type thing. I guess I should have paid attention to it. Thanks for reading and as you can/will see in later chapters, Sonic makes it clear that he has no romantic intentions with Amy. I could cement that idea in a confrontation between the two, and I might, but I have wanted to stay away from that for now. Thanks for the R&R!

Author's Response: speaking of errors, "live" should be "leave."


Name: Mechaknucles (Signed) · Date: September 22, 2007 2:32 PM · For: Questions and Misinterpretation
"Well that ends this chapter. I’m rather happy with this one."
I am happy with this one. I know you typed this prior to my last review being posted, but I decided to read a little more *Yay boredom!* and became fairly impressed. Maybe it is simply because it is not a retelling of events that passed, which was necessary for the story, but this chapter was good, exciting, and dramatic. The cliffhanger was excellent and convinces the reader to keep reading. I just hope you don't fall apart now! 9/10 (Yup, the legendary 9/10 exists!!)
Current score: 16/20 *A B!*


Name: Az The Dragon (Signed) · Date: September 22, 2007 8:22 AM · For: A Condemning Clarification
Well, nice fic you have here. I'll be waiting for next chapter

Author's Response: Please forgive me for freaking out a bit but oh my god! I LOVE your stuff, especially "Live, Open Your Heart, and Learn." I can't believe that you are reading my stuff! Thanks for the review!


Name: Nightshade (Signed) · Date: September 22, 2007 6:15 AM · For: A Condemning Clarification
I like that chapter It was well written and definatly interesting. I especially like when Sonic was suggesting the he'd get with Shadow if he was gay

Author's Response: That was meant to be more of a practical joke but hey, sometimes the truth comes out when we are "just kidding."


Name: Takashi the hedgehog (Signed) · Date: September 22, 2007 5:53 AM · For: A Condemning Clarification
Nice chapter title. Any who, the Sonic-gay-joke-thing was funny. XD Good place to put it too. Not to mention, the characters were in character and the writing was good. ^^ Great chapter, and sweet length.

Author's Response: Good to here that the characters still seem like themselves. I'm always crazy and worried about that when writing the dialogue. Thanks for the review as always!


Name: Nightshade (Signed) · Date: September 11, 2007 4:03 PM · For: Flawed Hypothesis
I'm glad you got around to updating because I like this story but those idead problems are a bugger I know....grr stupid idea problems....good job though I liked this chapter ^_^

Author's Response: Thanks for giving this another chance. Being an avid reader of fan fiction, I hate it when a writer abandons a story seemingly forever, and I'm very sorry for doing just that. Thanks for the R&R.


Name: Takashi the hedgehog (Signed) · Date: September 10, 2007 4:15 PM · For: Flawed Hypothesis
"Sonic had a mission to accomplish." XD Funny. Argh, though. You're making me feel the need to update. >< Any who, the end seems in character of Sonic. Not to mention the description was great. This was an awesome chap, and I'm glad to see this back up! ^^

Author's Response: I'm SOO glad that you liked it. I was really worried about how it would come out being away from it for so long. Thanks for the review as always.


Name: Nightshade (Signed) · Date: June 15, 2007 11:11 AM · For: Recovery
OOO I LOVE IT write more soon purty please


Name: Mechaknucles (Signed) · Date: May 11, 2007 10:11 PM · For: Success and Failure
"No one knew who said it, nor did they care. All that mattered was the response. They got that response in the form of a crushed hero solemnly shaking his head side to side, trying to hide his obviously frustrated eyes. The resulting silence was a terrible one, but Sonic soon broke it.

'Sayonara, Shadow the Hedgehog.' At these few words, the hero turned and exited the room" (More Than A Friendship).
First of all, your name sucks. Secondly, no, it is not boring. The description almost portrays the coldness and atmosphere of the space colony and battle. Lacking "triumph," the desctive detail delves fully into the spirailing death of Shadow. I copied the above quote because it is an absolutly wrong interpetation of events leading up to Sonic's "famous" line, "Sayonara, Shadow the Hedgehog" (Sonic Adventure 2).

The story is not bland, but it lacks interest. Because the first is a mere retelling of previously thought of events, it is your most poetic and strongest atmospheric setting. However, Sonic Team had more people and more time than you to make that come to life. Very good, 7/10

Author's Response: Thanks for the criticism! I know the name sucks, I probably should of taken more time on it. As for the ending of SA2, I didn't intend for it to be exactly like the game. I should've thrown up a 'Mild AU' warning I guess.
Thanks for your comments, I'll try my best to improve!


You must login (register) to review.

Sonic and Shadow (c) and TM SEGA - Sonic Team

Sonadow Online
http://www.sonadow.com
2003-2009